Who paid for what, Nick?

Nick Smith, following Bill English’s example, has apparently gone apoplectic about a media report concerning his Parliamentary expenses.

Eddie at The Standard rightly complains about Smith’s behaviour towards the media. But there may be more to the story than that.

Nick Smith claims:

I had to spend $152,000 to make it usable…

re his electorate office.

I don’t dispute that. But who paid the $152,000? Was it Smith personally? Or was at least some of it from a different Parliamentary budget from the one that pays for electorate office rents?

You see, each MP gets an annual allocation as an “expense allowance” (PDF, bottom of page 5) of $14,800 a year – I think it was somewhat less when Smith bought his Nelson office.

Now, that’s not a huge amount of money. But it can be used, and is used, for modifications and fitouts of electorate offices. And if there is capital expenditure charged against the allowance, only the depreciation will be charged in any given year.

So charge the cost of the fitout, improvements and chattel purchase on Nick Smith’s electorate office against that allowance, over the 13 years since he bought it, and it is possible it could all have been paid for almost entirely by a Parliamentary budget, rather than by Smith himself.

I’m not suggesting he did this – just that he could have done it.

Which surely has to be an argument for greater transparency re MPs’ expenses.

Nick Smith could take a lead in transparency re Parliamentary expenses here. He could front up and declare what he personally paid for, and what was paid by the various Parliamentary service budgets, for the electorate office he owns.

What are the chances he will?

5 thoughts on “Who paid for what, Nick?

  1. Outside bet, I’m giving odds of 30/1 at this point. I give 1/100 that he’ll carry on kicking off, and they’ll collectively end up in the paddy their British brethren are in about having to pay all this crap back and actually show the taxpayer what they’re doing with the money.

  2. He was apparently on the bones of his arse with all the court cases
    And know doesn’t he have a trust set up to help him them
    And then there’s the replacement caravans

  3. Yep, outofbed, I agree. But I’m just an author on this blog – not a techie who knows how to set that up.

    Will see what I can do though. I do know people I can ask how to do that.

    Or maybe you can tell me if you now more about WordPress than I do. My email address is vesna@ihug.co.nz.

  4. Pingback: Toad asks: Who paid for what, Nick? at The Standard

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s